One of the biggest decisions in any NYC bathroom renovation: keep the bathtub or go all-in on a walk-in shower? Here's how to make the right choice for your lifestyle and property.
The Case for Walk-In Showers
Walk-in showers have become increasingly popular in NYC apartments, particularly in:
- Master bathrooms where luxury and spa-like experiences are priorities
- Studio apartments where space optimization is critical
- Accessible designs that accommodate aging in place
- Modern renovations seeking a contemporary aesthetic
Benefits include easier cleaning, a more open feel, and often a better ROI for luxury listings.
When to Keep a Bathtub
There are several situations where a bathtub remains essential:
- Families with young children who need regular bath time
- Co-op buildings with requirements — some NYC co-ops mandate at least one bathtub per unit
- Resale considerations — buyers with children often specifically search for homes with bathtubs
- Relaxation preference — nothing beats a long soak after a hard day
The Hybrid Solution
The best of both worlds? Consider:
- Shower-tub combos — a walk-in shower with a removable panel that converts to a bathtub
- Wet room design — open floor plan where the entire bathroom is waterproofed, allowing both shower use and bath soaking
- Secondary bathroom strategy — install a walk-in shower in the master bath while keeping a traditional tub in the guest/rest bathroom
Making Your Decision
Ask yourself these questions:
- Does my building's board have any requirements?
- Who will be using this bathroom regularly?
- Do I plan to sell within 5-10 years?
- What's my priority: relaxation, accessibility, or modern aesthetics?
Still unsure? Our design consultants can help you evaluate your specific situation and create a bathroom that works for your lifestyle.